I had heard somewhere...
"bullshit can take you to the top, but cant keep u there..."
When it comes to the music scenario of India....i cant say the same....
Am not on a vacation now but can recall my ordeals last summer as i switched on the idiot box....now i know why it's called the idiot box...atleast wen it came to music, it had nothing to offer. I have been an ameateur composer myself and met many others like me...from various parts of india and though we have no dearth of talent, i have no reason not to assume that the future is goin to be worse....
Lets analyse the scenario step by step....first comes our own tradition of indian classical music.... Which unfortunately is like chess....u cannot enjoy the game without knowing the rules of it....as u become familliar with it it starts enchanting you like nothing that you have heard before.....
On my wayto mumbai in train i met 2 young musicians (like me...[:)]) Damien from australlia and Rastalucia from italy....they were country/ jazz artists and were trying to explore the depths of indian music....trying to acquire that 'critical mass' of knowledge that would enable them to fathom the depths of indian music.....They were a delight to talk to ....they were composing a song on GANGAJi... that was very touching to kno....
I am not trying to impress u with my appreciation of classical music but trying to bring home the fact that even ppl. from atotally different musical background can like and appreciate the Indian Classical music...because they want to know the rules of the game....they do not dismiss the game simply without trying to play it even once.....Sad is the state that we have rejected anything even remotely associated with classical music....but it is a fact that whenever these classical maestroes have come upfront commercially, they have created magic like never before...(remember shubha mudgal in ab ke saawan or ustad sultan khan in piya basanti?)
Sans appreciation the line of classical musicians is dying out in a country where music is not even a commercial sellout...but is commercial bullshit....
Now consider the folk legacy we have....artists like sharada sinha and the mangniyars of rajasthan....But when it comes to regional music....say a bhojpuri song.....'chailla bihari and manoj tiwari" with their shameless songs is the pick. I remember sitting with my sis after a long jog in morabadi maidaan in the nearby rama temple....They turned on the loudspeakers for the 'bhajans'.....shocking it is that instead of playing an Anup jalota or Hariom sharan song, they play some stupid parody of A himesh song...... urging God " Ek Baaar AAJA AAJA......SSSSS"
Now if i was God.... i wud have come "ek baar" so spell doom upon that stupid pujaari with my teesri ankh....
How can youth even like a song of folk genre when he/she is exposed to such crap in the name of folk music? So u kno what...ppl assume that folk itself is crap and reject it....'
Now coming to nON FILMY- INDIPOP\rock GENRE.....We were exposed to the wave of remixes, where a song was not known by the singer, but by the item girl who danced in it.....I am not totally against remixes....liked one or too long back like 'parde me rehne do" by asha bhosle and 'Noorie' by Baali Sagoo.... But what was served on the platter later was simply unacceptable....It is such a disgrace that i better not talk about it....
We do not have the BAND culture here in India, Unlike pakistan with notable exceptions such as euphoria and the Indian Ocean....but how much does quality music sell? It is restricted to the classes andf the masses donot appreciate it because their conception of music has been made so warped by what they are frequently exposed to in the name of music.....What sells is soulless music by JAZZY B, some stupid anglicised pseudo indian Rappers and stuff? It is a torture to the mind, body and soul to listen to such 'acclaimed' artists.....
Now coming to filmi music.....ya its big....so big that it has cast its shadow on all types of music prevalent....whatever i write may not apply to some great musicians who are a saving grace...the last hpoe for hapless music starvrd people....
First of all, no orignality..... I heard the music of the movie gangster and liked it....but alas, such has become the state of our industry that if something is good, i get suspicious.... mOST SONGS FROM GANGSTER ARE BLUNT COPIES...EVEN THE POPULAR SONG FROM WOH LAMHE!!!! Better not talk about it ....so lets talk about quality....
Firstly, lyrics are lame..... was watching a song from movie VIVAH in the mess recently....
Wanna write a song? technique#1:
The lyrics of a romantic song:
"Mujhe haq hai, tujhe dekhoon...dekhta hi rahoon...
piya piya boole mera jiya"
Now this song is from a big banner movie...the song and the video must have cost half a crore to make!!!! with such banal , cliche lyrics? Even my mallu friend from saudi arabia can write better lyrics in hindi!!!!!
And i am not joking....people with no formal training write such good songs in bands, but here we have a famous...professional lyricist??
Technique#2 for lyrics....dont have any lyrics...just repeat the same damn word for one whole line of the meloday; as in( "junoo jonooo junooo junooo)(multiplied by three) or "tera tera tera sasur" .....
Technique #3 Write hinglish songs like "Crazy kiya re" and "my love 4 u is not a one night stand"
Technique #4 Howl with meaningless sounds for the entire melody: eg"
OOOOOOOOOOOO ASHIK BANAYA...."
there are many more....but there are limits to my typing speeed...
Lyrics are important...just see a part of the lyrics of the great song by bob dylan
Like a rolling stone:
"Once upon a time you dressed so fine
You threw the bums a dime in your prime, didn't you?
People'd call, say, "Beware doll, you're bound to fall
"You thought they were all kiddin' you
You used to laugh about
Everybody that was hangin' out
Now you don't talk so loud
Now you don't seem so proud
About having to be scrounging for your next meal
How does it feel
How does it feel
To be without a home
Like a complete unknown'
Like a rolling stone?
You've gone to the finest school all right, Miss Lonely
But you know you only used to get juiced in it
And nobody has ever taught you how to live on the street
And now you find out you're gonna have to get used to it
You said you'd never compromise
With the mystery tramp, but now you realize
He's not selling any alibis
As you stare into the vacuum of his eyes
And ask him do you want to make a deal?
How does it feel
How does it fee
To be on your own
With no direction home
Like a complete unknown
Like a rolling stone?
see the difference? ... music is about feelings, about revolution...and u need lyrics to convey some thing for that.
Coming to the melody, i feel sad to think that we donot have talent in the industry....Surprisingly where every other college band has a good composition of its own, our great musicians have to beg, borrow and steal for their melodies....the original they create have no original orchestration, just techno beats and lack soul...just think what the chartbuster "crazy kiya re" is like.
There is no orignality with people bound to stereotypes.
And talking of such innovative methods, one just cannot getaway without mentioning the masters of the art- the great himesh reshammia, pritam et al.....
How can people buy such bullshit crap?" today if reshammia is the king and compares himself to rd burman or brayan adams in public, who is 2 balme? its only us...sadly....
Whenever there is a talent hunt to find a good singer, i feel the twinge of the same frustration.....a singer is onlly as good as a composition....if crazy kiya re was sung by lata, even then i wud consider it the same bullshit. Why dont we have a talent hunt for composers and artists and not only for people who learn a song by rote, rewindind the tape fifty times to learn a song? These talent shows, particularly the recent ones, are filled with people who look better than they sing....If they want models and belly flaunting babes instead of singers, why not try miss India? The worst thing about the indian film music is that "na khud sudharta hai, na baaki forms ko aage badhne deta hai..."
And lastly, The western music we indians hear is mostly limited to peppy stuff like ronan keating, shakira or to heavy death metal..... we have not been exposed to mature forms...even rock music all over the world is deteriorating fast....from the age where music was salvation, music was revolution, music was life , we are drifting into an age where music is bullshit..
Jim morrison said longtime back "rock is dead now"
I got 2 say before i sign off "Indian music is dead now....."